Vote of no confidence in North Yorkshire police boss Philip Allott as he refuses to resign over Sarah Everard remarks
Just 134 days after starting as North Yorkshire and York’s Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Philip Allott was confronted with dozens of demands for him to resign as he appeared before the area’s Police, Fire and Crime Panel, the only local body in the area which can hold him to account.
Appealing to the panel to support him in continuing in the £74,400-a-year job, Mr Allott said he had given a “car crash of an answer” in comments on Radio York that had been grossly insensitive.
He added the fury his initial comments had generated had been exacerbated by being “continually played back on BBC Look North”.
The Tory commissioner said as someone who had experience domestic abuse – and that he classified himself as “a survivor” – he was in a good position to understand the need to protect victims.
Mr Allott told the panel he had already approved a programme to identify potential offenders early, and highlighted schemes to create 400 new street lights and safe female refuges.
He said: “I am more than ever committed to protecting women and girls. My actions speak louder than words.”
Mr Allott read letters from numerous charities and women’s abuse groups stating they were willing to work or meet with him despite the comments and he highlighted how the Archbishop of York had warned against judging people over “15 minutes of madness”.
Nevertheless, the panel was told a total of more than 1,000 complaints had been made about Mr Allott’s comments, and the underlying expression of anger was over his “victim blaming”.
The panel heard most complainants believed the remarks implied the responsibility for keeping women from harm lay solely with women and betrayed a lack of understanding by Mr Allott about the issues that Miss Everard had faced before she was murdered.
One resident said it had been “gut-wrenching” that most of the commissioner’s staff had accused him of sexism and misogyny in a letter to the panel, less than three years after the panel had ruled against his predecessor, Julia Mulligan, for her treatment of staff.
Richmondshire councillor Helen Grant told the commissioner his comments could not be unsaid and that she was extremely saddened Sarah Everard’s family had to endure “the circus created by your comments”.
Harrogate district panel member Mike Chambers told Mr Allott: “This will continually haunt you Philip. You paid no regards to the concerns girls and women have going about their daily lives. I would ask you as a man of honour to fall on your sword.”
The committee’s chairman, Councillor Carl Les, told Home Office officials watching the virtual meeting that there needed to be legislative change to create a right of recall for the political post of commissioner as there is for MPs.
The meeting heard the panel’s powers were limited to “informal resolution” by making recommendations to the commissioner, but instead they held a vote of no confidence in Mr Allott, which was unanimous.
Coun Les told Mr Allott he was facing “a catastrophic loss of confidence”, adding: “Only you can resign, we cannot make you, and there is a frustration in that.”
Mr Allott replied that lived relived making the comments “every hour of the living day” and he could see “tensions are running high”, He said if everyone resigned who made a mistake nothing would get done in the country.
He said if he could not regain people’s trust he would “do the honourable thing”.
Mr Allott said: “This issue will haunt me whether I walk or don’t walk. I genuinely believe I can win back confidence and that will take time. I am under no illusion as to the feeling of the panel or the views of the people who have written.”
By Stuart Minting, Local Democracy Reporter