Notable moment as Harrogate Town Council breaks silence over threat to Rotary Wood

Harrogate Town Council has voted to oppose Harrogate Spring Water’s expansion plans.

At last week’s meeting, town councillors finally agreed to form a view on the premium bottled water brand’s controversial proposals which would see the destruction of trees at Rotary Wood and all but one agreed to say ‘no’.

For the actual vote, three town councillors left the room, as they sit on North Yorkshire Council’s planning committee – Paul Haslam, Chris Aldred and Michael Harrison.

And Coun Elizabeth Jackson (Tory, Oatlands) abstained on the question of whether to object to the application.

Coun Mike Schofield (Independent for Harlow and St Georges Division) who called for Harrogate Town Council to oppose Harrogate Spring Water's expansion plans. (Picture contributed)placeholder image
Coun Mike Schofield (Independent for Harlow and St Georges Division) who called for Harrogate Town Council to oppose Harrogate Spring Water's expansion plans. (Picture contributed)

During the meeting, Coun Mike Schofield (Independent, Harlow and St George’s), argued that Harrogate Town Council had a duty to consider all that has happened and then take a stand on the issue.

Harrogate Town Council, was formed in April 2025, following the abolition of Harrogate Borough Council in April 2023.

Until now, the council had opted not to comment, taking the view that it had been in existence when the initial planning application by Harrogate Spring Water has been submitted in 2017.

Coun Mike Schofield argued that this, in itself, was no reason not to participate in the issue.

Lib Dem councillor Graham Dixon (Lib Dem, Harlow) asked the Council to consider the application following its recent deferral by the Harrogate and Knaresborough Area Planning Committee .

During the debate that followed, Coun Dixon argued that Harrogate Spring Water’s expansion plans were not what the community wanted, saying that the trees at Rotary Wood on Harlow Hill were almost mature and the area was an asset of community value.

He questioned whether Harrogate Borough Council had been right to approve Harrogate Spring Water’s plans in the first place.

He and Councillor Goodall also questioned the veracity of claims by the water company that the project would boost the local economy.

Councillor Mark Warr (Lib Dem, Pannal) cited a recent survey by Suffrago showing that the majority of respondents did not support the firm's redevelopment.

He said: “This Council should not oppose investment or development in Harrogate lightly.

"However, this proposal is just in the wrong place.”

After the vote, Coun Mike Schofield said: “This is great news and I want to thank the town council for standing up for what’s right.

"I hope that they will stick to the facts when putting together their views, as some points made about Harrogate Spring Water were heartfelt but not necessarily persuasive in planning terms.”

Coun Josie Caven (Lib Dem, Kingsley) will represent the committee’s views to the Harrogate and Knaresborough Area Planning Committee when it meets to make a final decision on the expansion.

News you can trust since 1836
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice