'Last minute' intervention by councillors over Harrogate Spring Water’s expansion plans

The Green Party has thrown a new argument into the long-running debate over Harrogate Spring Water’s expansion plans with claims that it may impact negatively on groundwater and Harrogate’s network of 90 springs.

As North Yorkshire Council confirmed it will hold a crucial meeting on April 17 and news seeps out that council officers have recommended the application be granted, it should be noted that this does not mean councillors will approve it.

Having previously deferred a decision on the reserved matters application, ie the details only, amid strong objections over the loss of around 500 trees in Rotary Wood, the ultimate decision rests, as it always has, with councillors, not officers.

Now local Green Party councillors Arnold Warneken and Mike Schofield have raised questions about whether hydrological impacts have been fully considered in the planning process.

Local Green Party councillors Arnold Warneken and Mike Schofield have raised questions about whether hydrological impacts have been fully considered in the planning process for Harrogate Spring Water’s controversial expansion plans. (Picture contributed)placeholder image
Local Green Party councillors Arnold Warneken and Mike Schofield have raised questions about whether hydrological impacts have been fully considered in the planning process for Harrogate Spring Water’s controversial expansion plans. (Picture contributed)

The Green councillors have written to the Head of Planning at North Yorkshire Council to request that a new Environmental Screening is carried out, to address the impact of Harrogate Spring Water’s development on groundwater and Harrogate’s network of 90 springs.

The Greens claim that the Council’s ecologist said this work needed to be done but could be carried out later, which the Greens say is unacceptable.

Coun Arnold Warneken, who represents the Ouseburn Division, said: “If you make decisions like this without looking at impact, you’re making decisions in the dark.

"You can tell the committee that they’re looking at layout and landscaping but a survey might change how all that is done.

"Never mind what the development looks like - there’s a risk here that irreparable damage might be done.”

Coun Mike Schofield, councillor for Harlow and St Georges, the division where Harrogate Spring Water is located, said: “Water is the whole lifeblood of Harrogate Spring Water’s brand.

"And it’s Harrogate’s, too. Our town lies on a network of over 90 springs, two of which are on site.

"They are an incredibly delicate ecosystem.

"Why wouldn’t you check the impact? There’s a risk that irreparable damage will be done.”

This Friday’s planning meeting takes place at 2pm at Harrogate Civic Centre.

News you can trust since 1836
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice