Is there a way forward for major Harrogate town centre plans which have run out of support and purpose
The £12 million Harrogate Gateway scheme may have already been approved by councillors but the debate around this attempt to transform the town centre is far from settled.
The original version of this major project to promote non-car travel measures such as walking, cycling and public transport in the Station Parade area and give it a visual freshen-up for visitors was significantly watered down last year.
North Yorkshire Council did so after the owner of Hornbeam Park Developments, Chris Bentley, who owns commercial property in Harrogate town centre, joined forces with fellow Harrogate businessman and philanthropist Dr Terry Bramall CBE in 2023 to threaten North Yorkshire Council with a judicial review of the project.
But losing the subsequent battle in the High Court has not deterred Harrogate business leaders from continuing their campaign to have the entire scheme scrapped six long years after the council first set the wheels in motion for Gateway as part of then Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s Transforming Cities Fund initiative.


Instead, Get Away, the campaign group representing businesses opposed to Gateway, has been granted permission for a review of the High Court decision’s to dismiss its legal challenge against North Yorkshire Council’s traffic regulation orders made to progress the contentious project.
The council shows no signs of making any further concessions, arguing that, from a legal perspective, the appeal relates to four traffic regulation orders, not the scheme itself.
It has now signed the contracts for constructors to break ground and begin real work in Harrogate town centre in January.
Steven Baines, spokesperson for the Get Away campaign: “The council wants to take a hard long look at itself.


"They need to ask themselves whether this is morally right.
"If there was a review relating to any other development in the town, would they let it go ahead?”
"Between the drastic parking cuts and two years of disruptive construction, it’s clear that footfall will take a serious hit and so, too, will businesses in the area."
It is difficult to argue that Harrogate town centre is in any way short of parking spaces within five minutes walking time from the shops – or less.


But campaigners claim the revised version of Gateway, though it would no longer see the pedestrianisation of James Street or the reduction of vehicular traffic to one lane on Station Parade, would still involve parking being reduced on Lower Station Parade from 23 spaces down to three.
They also claim there has been a lack of public consultation on the project, though North Yorkshire Council points to the fact it has already held three rounds of consultation on its proposals.
Ironically, Harrogate businesses are more opposed to Gateway than ever despite forcing the removal of most of the measures they had been opposing.
Equally, North Yorkshire Council is determined to press on with a project which has lost much of its original purpose.
In this context, whatever the rights and wrongs of trying to tackle Harrogate’s addiction to the motor car, the idea of ploughing ahead with months of disruption to trade in the town centre in the midst of a cost of living crisis must now be in question.
Such is the lengthy and perplexing nature of the story of Harrogate Gateway, it seems highly unlikely that anyone will ever again so lightly contemplate a project of this nature or scale.
If history teaches us anything, it’s that Harrogate has a long history of scepticism towards major town centre redevelopments, from plans in 1970 for a concrete flyover in the town centre to the fiasco in 2017 over a proposed £75 million makeover of Harrogate Borough Council’s former offices at Crescent Gardens.
Both were abandoned in the face of mounting opposition from a town that never likes to be taken for granted.