Harrogate's bottled water firm says planning rules 'back them up' on Rotary Wood controversy

At the same time as opponents are complaining that Harrogate Spring Water’s business expansion plans lack a full environmental report, the famous bottled water firm has issued “clear evidence” that planning rules don’t require one.

After a recent planning meeting of North Yorkshire Council voted to defer a decision on the company’s proposals, which would see the removal of two acres of community woodland at Rotary Wood, opponents have continued to argue that councillors should not give the go-ahead in the absence of an Environmental Impact Assessment.

But Harrogate Spring Water, owned since 2020 by multi-national giant Danone, has hit back, telling the Harrogate Advertiser that outline planning permission granted by councillors in 2017 does not necessitate one.

The premium bottled company points out that, on the council ’s planning portal for application HGT20/01539/REMMAJ, there’s an EIA screening which sets out clearly why an Environmental Impact Assessment wasn’t required.

An artist's impression of Harrogate Spring Water's expansion plans on Harlow Hill near the Pinewoods. (Picture contributed)placeholder image
An artist's impression of Harrogate Spring Water's expansion plans on Harlow Hill near the Pinewoods. (Picture contributed)

A spokesperson for Harrogate Spring Water, which has pledged to plant thousands of new trees, said: “We have worked constructively with council officers and engaged with the community to ensure our plans align with planning policy and reflect the commitments we have made.

"The planning documents (including S106 and Condition 12) provide certainty for both the community and the council and strike the right balance between sustainable development and economic growth.”

In the meantime, Harrogate independent councillor Mike Schofield (Harlow and St George’s) has written to Natural England and the Environment Agency asking for clarification on environmental impacts of the Harrogate Spring Water factory expansion.

“This is a sensitive woodland site involving priority habitats and complex drainage condition,” said Coun Schofield.

"Given the scale of the proposal and the number of missing ecological and hydrological assessments, I do not see how anyone can have confidence that all environmental impacts have been properly considered.

"Residents deserve clear answers and, right now, many of those answers are missing.”

Outstanding information which would form part of a full EIA would include bat surveys, amphibian and reptile surveys, a lighting assessment, a full tree survey, habitat assessments, infiltration testing, hydrological modelling and more.

Harrogate’s MP has also called on the government to intervene in the planning application.

The proposal for the expansion of its bottling plant on Harlow Hill would see around 500 trees in Rotary Wood removed, though the premium bottled water brand has announced plans to replace them with approximately 3,000 new trees in the area.

As opponents await a new date for the long-delayed planning decision, Tom Gordon, Liberal Democrat MP for Harrogate and Knaresborough, says it is time for Steve Reed MP, the secretary of state for housing, communities, and local government to step in.

In his letter to the government, Mr Gordon urged intervention by the minister on the grounds of what he said were “serious failings in the planning process”.

"The failure to carry out the environmental impact assessment appears to be a fundamental breach of planning law and casts serious doubt on the legality of both the outline permission and the current application,” said Mr Gordon.

"This is a statutory requirement for developments with significant environmental impacts, and chopping down hundreds of trees clearly meets that threshold.

"The secretary of state must intervene to ensure the process is lawful and to restore public confidence in the integrity of the planning system.”

Last month Mr Gordon called a public meeting to save Rotary Wood, joining forces with local campaigners and around 70 members of the public.

There are concerns mitigation measures have not been identified, alternative options have not been considered, and the cumulative environmental impacts have not been assessed.

He warned that allowing the application to proceed without proper environmental assessment risks setting a dangerous precedent that undermines the integrity of the planning system.

He is urging ministerial intervention to ensure the application is handled lawfully, transparently, and with full consideration of the environmental consequences.

Harrogate Spring Water says its expansion would bring 50 new jobs and an annual £2.3 million boost to the local economy.

News you can trust since 1836
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice