Green councillor's plea to Harrogate Spring Water to 'go back to the drawing board'
Harrogate Spring Water’s long-debated expansion plans have been hit by a new blow.
After holding a series of public consultations over the last 12 months, the bottled water company had announced its revised version of the scheme would include creating a new publicly accessible woodland on two acres of land near the existing Harrogate Spring Water operations on Harlow Moor Road.But, if the iconic Harrogate spa brand,
which, since 2020, has been part of the Danone empire which also owns Evian and Volvic, had been hoping responding to public concern over the loss of trees at Rotary Wood would end a row that has gone on for seven years, recent events illustrate the gulf remains.
A week after Harrogate and Knaresborough MP Tom Gordon announced he was still opposed to the expansion despite the revisions, a Harrogate Green councillor now says Harrogate Spring Water needs to go back to the drawing board and submit an entire new plan to North Yorkshire Council precisely because of all the changes.


It’s a line of attack completely rejected by Harrogate Spring Water but, nonetheless, Arnold Warneken, Councillor for Ouseburn Division at North Yorkshire Council, confirmed to the Harrogate Advertiser that he had written to the planners regarding the position relating to Harrogate Spring Water’s Design and Access Statements.
"The plans don’t now really now represent what the application was originally and I have asked for a new application,” said Coun Warneken.
Among what he claimed were the major design differences between the December 2016, May 2020, and February 2024 Design and Access Statements, are:
Building Scale and Development Platform: The differences
December 2016 Design: Initial concept proposed multiple options with a 4,800 square meter development platform.
It emphasized a balanced layout with flexibility to either extend toward the northwestern boundary (with a visible feature elevation) or maintain a more concealed approach with perimeter planting(16_05254_OUTMAJ-Design_…).
May 2020 Design: Restricted development size to 4,794 square meters, following the existing northern boundary with minimal public visibility.
This design adhered strictly to a low-profile, functional form, without elevated or visibly prominent sections(20_01539_REMMAJ-SUPERSE…).
February 2024 Design: Expanded to a 5,458 square meter facility with elevated building sections to accommodate site topography.The design includes visible, glazed
elevations, breaking from the purely functional form of 2020(20_01539_REMMAJ-DESIGN_…).
Harrogate Spring Water argues there are no grounds for an entire new application for its plans to expand its bottling plant to meet growing demand for its spa water.
A spokesperson for the company said: “The amendment of a scheme and its design is commonplace in planning applications and in no way impacts upon the principle of the development or the approved outline planning application. Normal process has been followed.
"Therefore, there are no grounds for an entire new application.
“Following extensive consultation with stakeholders, the public and council officers we have amended elements such as the design of the building and landscaping.
"This has been in direct response to the feedback we have received.
"These changes, including the addition of new publicly accessible space, are positive amendments to address concerns raised.
“The principle of the development, to expand our facility, was established with the granting of outline planning permission.
"As is the norm, this occurred with the details of the scale, layout, external appearance and landscaping needing to be approved through a subsequent reserved matters application.”