Woman jailed after filming boyfriend hanging out of car before fatal crash in Harrogate
A woman who drove in her socks and used her mobile phone to film her boyfriend hanging out of a passenger window has been jailed for three years after her car crashed into a ditch in Harrogate, causing his death.
Mia Howarth, 21, was just 18-years-old when the horror crash occurred on Brimham Rocks Road on the evening of September 12, 2023, York Crown Court heard.
Prosecutor Chloe Hudson said Howarth had been “locking and unlocking” various apps and was filming her boyfriend, Alfie Lovett, 17, and another boy as they leaned out of the car windows shortly before the crash.
Ms Hudson said there was “shouting and loud music” inside the car in the moments before the accident which resulted in the death of Alfie who had become a father just 12 weeks before the accident.


“At one point the camera panned to the defendant,” added Ms Hudson.
A Snapchat video recorded at 6.37pm captured Alfie partially outside the car just seconds before the vehicle left the road. The court heard that Alfie, who had apparently removed his seatbelt, was later ejected from the car when it veered off the road and into a ditch, near Stripe Lane in Hartwith. Alfie suffered fatal chest injuries.
Two days after the fatal crash, a man went into Fulford Road Police Station in York and handed officers footage of Alfie hanging out of the window just before being flung from the car.
This footage had been taken by the rear-seat passenger and shared with the man who gave the film to police.
“That footage showed Mr Lovett was on the near-side windowsill, his feet on the near-side front passenger seat with his whole body outside the car, facing the offside,” said Ms Hudson.
An accident investigation by a specialist traffic officer concluded that Howarth’s vehicle, which was doing about 35mph and wasn’t speeding, began to “veer gently to the near side” as Howarth turned to her left and used her phone to film Alfie.
The vehicle crossed a grass verge and struck a ditch, with damage consistent with a glancing impact against a stone wall. Alfie was caught between the car and the wall.
There had been two male passengers in the back seat of the car during the ill-fated journey.
Howarth and others attempted to help Alfie at the scene. When police arrived, she admitted responsibility.
The court heard Howarth had owned the car for only a month and had passed her driving test around a year earlier. She said she had removed her shoes because they were slipping off the pedals.
She pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving. In a statement read to the court, Alfie’s family described him as “unique in so many ways”.
His mother said he was “funny, caring and fiercely protective” and spoke of her pride in him as a new father.
Defence barrister Glenn Parsons said Howarth, of Cooperative Street in Horbury, Wakefield, was deeply remorseful and had been affected “every moment” since the tragedy. He added that she had left her job as a care home manager due to the emotional strain.
Sentencing, Judge Sean Morris described her actions as a “highly dangerous manoeuvre” and said she should have stopped the car.
He noted that Howarth had a previously impeccable record and had shown “obvious remorse” and that any sentence he imposed could “never mend the broken hearts in this case”.
While acknowledging her previous good character, he said the consequences were devastating.
Howarth was sentenced to three years in prison and banned from driving for 30 months.