Now, as part of a major transformation of the Royal Pump Room, the question of whether we should be able to drink the water again is back on the agenda, and was debated at the latest museum stakeholder meeting.
The group has been launched to gather views and ideas from Harrogate residents about how changes to the museum could take shape. In May this year, Harrogate Borough Council announced an investment of Â£150,000 towards the refurbishment, and excitement about improving the visitor experience was already building at the well-attended meeting held in the Mercer Art Gallery.
The organiser of Harrogate's Pride in Diversity festival, and group member, Leonora Wassell, whose father-in-law used to drink the water every day while he worked at the Royal Pump Room Museum, told the Advertiser that being able to offer the experience again could be an important part of bringing the town's history to life, for both locals and visitors.
Leonora said: "Certainly for people to be able to come in and experience things - to not just look at them, but experience them in an interactive way, is very important.
"If you had different bottles of water for people to try, it makes the experience that bit more engaging. Drinking the water gives a sense of what people thought at the time, about the health benefits of it, and how they were concerned about the wellbeing of people.
"This is about making the museum alive. I am passionate about history, but it should be living history."
There was also talk at the meeting about ways of bringing the historic building back to how it was originally, and how the space could also be used more as a community hub.
The curator of the Royal Pump Room Museum, May Catt, said: "We are doing some important fundraising work at the moment to really see how we can re-display the museum and perhaps bring the building back to how it was originally.
"We are asking particular questions - for example, could we drink the water again? Could we reveal more of the glass in the 1913 extension, and bring the building back to life? Could it be lit up at night, and could we have different types of activities to bring in more local audiences?
"We are really encouraging local people to give us their views about how they might imagine a new and improved museum."
Another hot topic discussed by the group was how to drive an increase in repeat local visitors to the museum, and make the most of the space to possibly introduce new features on a more regular basis.
Unveiling themed exhibitions closely tied in with national news and events was suggested by the group as a potential way of keeping the museum's appeal current
Leonora said: "It is about being relevant, and having that engagement. When you have got things happening nationwide, this would show that Harrogate is making connections, and connecting history with the present.
"You could tie in with things like LGBT history month, refugees, and equality. It would be showing residents and people visiting that the museum is current, that it is reacting to things in the news."
Another suggestion thrown around to look at making the visitor experience more immersive was the idea of being assigned an illness or a specific ailment when you walk through the door - visitors would then be that character throughout, finding out what sort of treatments they would have had.
What would you like to see at the Royal Pump Room Museum? Get in touch - email me: [email protected], or call 01423 707505.